Wine & Cheese Pairing #2

I was planning on attending the regular Thursday wine tasting today, but Blacksburg did it's usual surprise snow thing again and the Vintage Cellar closed at 4:00.  Instead of just abandoning the wine quest all together, I got my friends Oliver and Maggie and my awesome, down-for-anything boyfriend Will to have a wine and cheese party!  We headed next door to Kroger and stocked up on wine.  I took advantage of Rex Goliath's insanely well-priced deal and purchased a Free Range Red and a Pinot Grigio.  Maggie bought a Llama Malbec, and we also picked up wedges of gouda, jarlsburg, and manchego cheese.

Wine #1 - Rex Goliath Pinot Grigio
We started with whites and worked to full bodied reds like I now know you're supposed to.  This pinot grig was VERY light in color with a pale greenish/yellow tint.  It smelled absolutely delightful with honey, honeycrisp apple, grapefruit and a hint of butterscotch.  Unfortunately, it did not taste as great as it smelled.
Alone - it tasted like apple juice with a citrus finish.  The overwhelming flavors were apple and honey.  Note that I didn't chill this wine.  If I had, I don't think it would have tasted like anything at all.
Gouda - The gouda cut whatever acidity this wine had to begin with (read:not much at all) and made it taste like straight up apple juice.
Jarlsburg -  This was an okay pair, and rather than changing the flavor, it did something strange to the texture turning the Jarlsburg into what I imagine is the consistency of ear wax.
Manchego - The manchega stripped the sweetness out of the wine and made it taste like you were chewing on the end of a good old Ticonderoga number 2 pencil.

Wine #2 - Rex Goliath Free Range Red
This was a deep plum colored wine that smelled leathery, spicy, black cherry, oaky and earthy.
Alone - It tasted like spice, like you took a big bite of the skin of a Christmas ham and got a clove in there, too.  This wine had NO acidity at all, and you felt tannins on the back part of the roof of your mouth.
Gouda - Yum!  This combo was so drinkable at first sip.  The cheese became more buttery and pungent, and the tannins were gone from the wine so it effectively tasted like grape juice.  I tried this combo later on, though, and the combo made the wine taste TOO sugary.
Jarlsburg - The Jarls and the Red mix totally cancelled each other out in a confusing combo that left you wondering what exactly was in your mouth.
Manchego - Oh yum!  This combo takes the mild cheese and adds more dimension to bring out the advertised jamminess of the wine.  This was a close tie with the gouda for best pair.

Wine #3 - Llama Malbec - According to Maggie, this wine had a 93 rating when she picked it up from Kroger.  It had a pretty dark amethyst/garnet color and smelled like cassis, strawberries, and tomatoes.  It definitely smelled like a spicy old vine Malbec.
Alone - This wine had more tannins and acidity but the same amount of alcohol as the previous wine.  It tasted like it had half of a prune, metal, and a tiny bit like bile on the finish (but in a good way somehow).
Gouda - The fruit comes out to play with this combination.  I caught hints of blueberry and what couldn't be mango but sure did taste like it.  This relatively thick wine was turned to the consistency of grape juice.
Jarlsburg - Ew, this tasted bad with Jarls.  We have got to find a wine that this cheese will play nicely with, because this really doesn't work.  It seemed like they brought out the worst in each other with waxy swissy cheese and thin flavorless acidy wine.  My disgust could stem from the fact that I really don't like swiss cheese, so take this as my own opinion.
Manchego - This combo let the Manchego become buttery and stronger in flavor.  It stripped the thickness out of the wine and didn't leave it with much flavor.

This wine and cheese pairing experiment wasn't quite as successful as the first experiment.  I learned that there is, in fact, a reason why the Rex's were so inexpensive.  They really weren't balanced or developed wines to begin with, so with cheese, they almost lost all their flavor.  Til next time!